
| |
| What Is The Scientific Basis Of
Chiropractic Medicine? |
|
(this section is written considering Medical Physicians as
the primary audience) |
| Chiropractic is based upon three related scientific
theories: |
|
1. Pathological disease
processes may be influenced by disturbances of the nervous system. Many factors have been
implicated as impairing health, such as hereditary and genetic anomalies; improper rest;
lack of exercise; inadequate and improper nutrition; overindulgence; foods tainted by
pesticides, insecticides, herbicides, fertilizers and preservatives; improperly cooked
and/or processed foods; contaminated water; air pollution; stress, bodily insults and
trauma; and the relative virulence and density of pathogenic organisms (bacteria and
viruses). In addition to these factors, disturbances of the nervous system mediated
primarily by the musculoskeletal system may also be an important factor contributing to
disease etiology. Chiropractic maintains that proper structural and biomechanical
integrity are important for the maintenance of homeostatic balance and resistance to
disease. Agents that irritate bodily organs and structures, upset homeostasis, precipitate
a bodily response that is mediated in part by the nervous system. An impaired nervous
system may diminish the body's defensive capabilities, its ability to adapt to internal or
external stress and environmental change thus contributing to its susceptibility to
disease etiology. Conversely, an impaired nervous system may affect adversely homeostatic
balance, lowering bodily resistance as sometimes evidenced by functional disturbances
without overt pathology, and which tend to weaken the body's ability to resist disease. In
this manner, the nervous system may be the root of some pathological process. |
|
2. Disturbances of the
nervous system may be the result of derangements of the musculoskeletal structure. Two
broad and otherwise general theories have been identified in chiropractic by scientific
researchers. One has been called the "biomechanics hypothesis," and the other
the "nerve compression hypothesis."(1) According to research scientists, the
former consists of "chronic vertebral deviations (classical subluxations) or postural
defects which may put mechanical strain on soft tissues associated with the spine: the
periosteum, ligaments, fibrous capsules of joints, discs, as well as tendons, fascia and
body muscles. These tissues form an essential part of the spine as a mechanical system,
enabling it to support large loads through a wide range of movement. If the mechanical
disorder is uncorrected, the soft tissue may undergo change, and these would exacerbate
the disorder. Thus, discs may undergo thinning or protrusion. Ligaments and joint capsules
may become fibrotic and thickened. Such changes would often tend to aggravate the
mechanical disorder, further disturbing the normal alignment of the vertebrae. Stretched
muscles would tend to contract, owing to reflex servomechanisms, and possibly go into
spasms or sustained contraction. The resultant asymmetry of forces may again exacerbate
the mechanical malfunctioning. "These effects, sustained muscle contraction and
irritation of the deep tissues of the spine are potential sources of pain. Deep pain,
originating in the soft tissues of the spine may be referred to peripheral structures,
especially if the sensory fibers from the latter enter the cord through the same dorsal
roots as those conveying pain signals from the affected tissue of the spine. The reflex
reaction to the pain itself may put additional tensions on the spine. In this way vicious
circles are established, which prevent restoration of normal mechanical relations within
the spine and at the same time, generate abnormal reflex activity, owing to stimulation of
pain receptors and reflex responses to stretch of muscles and tendons." (2) In
contrast, the nerve compression hypothesis contends that, "aberrant neural activity
results from mechanical disorders of the spine due to compression of spinal nerves at the
intervertebral foramina. This hypothesis still occupies a central place in the
chiropractic rationale ..." (3) The latter hypothesis above represents the
"classical subluxation" theory in chiropractic. Recent research in spinal and
musculoskeletal biomechanics is beginning to receive increased attention in this area.
Several important research developments in the past ten years underscore the need for more
research on this aspect of chiropractic theory. Recent studies have shown that the spinal
nerve roots appear to be uncharacteristically sensitive to pressure and compression in
contrast to previous studies on peripheral nerves. (4-6) According to Sharpless at the
University of Colorado, "...the dorsal [nerve] roots are exquisitely sensitive to
compression block when they are compressed within a few centimeters of their entrance to
the [spinal] cord, far more than had been previously supposed. Compound action potentials
representing volleys of nerve impulses in myelinatedfibers are reduced to about one-half
their normal values by a pressure of approximately 20 mm Hg. [mercury] in the roots...
" (5) and, "A pressure of only 10mm Hg. produced significant conduction block,
the potential [of nerve impulses] falling under 60 percent of its initial value in 15
minutes. With higher levels of pressure, we have observed incomplete recovery after many
hours of recording." (6) Further research has also shown that rapidly conducting and
large diameter nerve root fibers are the most susceptible to compression and pressure
blocks (7-9) and that small nerve fibers may be more sensitive to anoxia and ion
imbalances created by pressure on the nerve.(8-11) It has also been found that axoplasmic
flow, the movement of sustaining nutrients and chemical mediators is also susceptible to
various forms of compression. (9) Dr. Luttges (PhD) another researcher at the University
of Colorado has found that, "[nerve] compression produced by constrictive cuffs
(approximately one-third to one-half reduction in nerve diameter) was found to produce
degenerative effects different from, but as profound as, those produced by nerve
section." (10) Intervertebral subluxations have also found a place in medical
literature. In fact in the early 1950's Hadley found evidence of nerve root compression in
many postmortem examinations. These subluxations were particularly prevalent in the
cervical and lumbar areas of the spine. (11-16) More recently, Epstein indicated that
nerve root entrapment and compression may be responsible for such things as sciatica;
intermittent claudication, an ischemic condition; and other similar types of conditions.
(12) This closely parallels Sunderlands theory that "compression first leads to
venous obstruction followed by capillary circulation disturbances resulting in anoxia and
finally irreversible ischemic damage." Sunderland feels that in the absence of overt
pathology, e.g., osteophytic enlargement [osteo-arthritis], malignancies, etc., that
compression is the result of apophyseal joint swelling secondary to [classical]
subluxation of the joint and trauma to the capsule reducing the cross-sectional area of
the intervertebral foramen through which the nerve passes resulting in compressive
distortions of the tissues in the foramen. (13) Cailliet states that, "pain in and
from the neck results from the mechanical factor of encroachment of space and impairment
of movement. Decrease in the space in which pain-sensitive tissues lie or through which
they pass compresses these tissues, resulting in possible pain and loss of functions. Pain
is more apt to occur if pressure is acute and transient, whereas loss of function is more
likely as pressure is prolonged and continuous. The sites at with tissues are most likely
to compress are the intervertebral foramina and within the spinal canal. The tissues in
these specific areas are nerves and their coverings, blood vessels, ligaments, joint
capsules, and dura mater. Encroachment of space resulting in pressure upon these tissues
may result in pain or loss of function."(14) A prominent orthopedic surgeon and
researcher Kirkaldy-Willis claims that ninety percent (90%) of patients with low back pain
have "dysfunction," indicating that changes exhibited are mainly those of
abnormal function with slight anatomic changes to the three joint complex, the
intervertebral disc and zygapophyseal joints. Of the remaining ten percent (10%) he claims
that fifty percent (50%) of those have lateral nerve root entrapment. With dynamic
recurrent lateral entrapment there is a laxity of the posterior joints and of the annulus
causing abnormal movement of the vertebrae resulting in a narrowing of the lateral nerve
canal and tapping on the main spinal nerve as this passes along the canal. Dr.
Kirkaldy-Willis indicates that manipulation is an effective method of treatment for both
patients with dysfunction and lateral nerve root entrapment. (15) Other conditions
involving the motor and motion units of the spine are stretching and traction injuries to
the nerve roots and chronic irritations of the neural complex from adhesions,
osteoarthritis, fibrosis, etc. [nerve root entrapment], and disc lesions such as
herniations, discogenic diseases etc., will affect the neural complex. In all likelihood a
multiplicity of factors are responsible for the clinical manifestations that chiropractors
experience in practice rather than a single mechanism. Many of the different categories or
theories of causation, however, may be classified as variant forms of subluxations in
chiropractic so that the term "subluxation" assumes a broader and more diverse
meaning in chiropractic than in classical literature. The above information demonstrates,
albeit briefly, that musculoskeletal derangements may indeed have an affect on the nervous
system. Subluxations of vertebral and pelvic segments represent common chiropractic
mechanical clinical findings in man. Extended abnormal secondary involvement of the
nervous system may result from disturbances, strains, and stresses arising with the
musculoskeletal system due to mankind's attempt to maintain an erect posture. These
mechanical lesions or subluxations are a common result of gravitational strains,
asymmetrical activities and efforts, and developmental defects or other mechanical,
chemical, or psychic irritations of the nervous system. |
|
3. Disturbances of the
nervous system may aggravate pathological processes in various parts or with various
functions of the body. Vertebral and pelvis subluxations may be involved in common
functional disorders of a visceral and vasomotor nature, and at times may produce
phenomena that relate to the special organs. Under predisposing circumstances, almost any
component of the nervous system may directly or indirectly cause reactions within any
other component by means of reflex mediation. The conjunction of independent causes of
bodily dysfunction may jointly have more serious debilatory effects than either cause
might have had separately. Subluxations may contribute to the "triggering" or
exacerbating of certain types of neurovascular and neurovisceral instabilities. Correction
of the spinal [manipulative] lesion is often imperative for effective total management of
a patient's case. |
| Diagnostic Methods |
|
The doctor of
chiropractic conducts a systematic and thorough physical examination using the methods,
techniques, and instruments that are standard with all health professions. In addition, a
postural and spinal analysis is included. The chiropractic physician uses the standard
procedures and instruments of physical and clinical diagnosis and is well acquainted with
the need for differential diagnosis. Diagnostic roentgenology, especially as it relates to
the skeletal system, is a primary clinical diagnostic aid in chiropractic and has been
since the early 1900's. In addition, doctors of chiropractic are knowledgeable in the
standard clinical laboratory procedures and tests usual to modern diagnostic science. Each
accredited college has a laboratory licensed to carry on clinical laboratory examinations,
including work in cytology, chemistry, hematology, serology, bacteriology, parasitology,
and electrocardiography. |
| Treatment Methods |
|
Chiropractic treatment
methods are determined by the scope of practice authorized by Kansas law. Essentially,
treatment methods include chiropractic manipulation, necessary dietary advice and
nutritional supplementation, adjunctive physiotherapeutic and supportive measures, and
professional counsel. The most characteristic aspect of chiropractic practice is the
correction (reduction) of a subluxated vertebral or pelvic segment(s) by means of making a
specific, predetermined adjustment. The purpose of this correction and its determination
is to normalize the relationships of segments within their articular surfaces and relieve
any attendant neurological, muscular, and vascular disturbances. The corrective structural
adjustment by a chiropractic physician should not be confused with other forms of
manipulation. Manipulative therapy in one form or another is used in all the healing arts.
Mobilization is putting a joint through its normal range of motion, by a therapist, in
order to stretch muscles and break adhesions. Osteopathic manipulation is designed to
increase joint motion and relieve fixations. On the other hand, chiropractic corrective
adjustment is made only after careful analysis, delivered in a specific manner, to achieve
a predetermined goal. It is a precise, delicate maneuver, requiring special
bio-engineering skills and a deftness not unlike that required for other specialties.
Rarely is the process painful. Most chiropractic corrective adjustments involve the
articulation of the spinal column and extremities. Some techniques, however, are
light-touch reflex adjustments that involve the neurovascular, neurolymphatic, and
neuromuscular systems, gentle manipulation and passive mobilization. Vitamin and mineral
food supplementation can, if professionally supervised, serve to prevent the onset or
assuage the existence of some types of dysfunction of the nervous system and other
tissues. If deemed necessary in case management, dietary regimens and nutritional
supplementation are often advised as adjunctive therapy. Physiotherapeutic methods and
procedures are frequently used as adjunctive therapy to enhance the effects of the
chiropractic adjustments. Such procedures may include the use of diathermy, galvanic
currents, infrared and ultraviolet light, ultrasound, traction, paraffin baths, hot or
cold compresses, acupuncture, hydrotherapy, heel or sole lifts, foot orthotics, and other
commonly utilized modalities when indicated. Taping and strapping and other forms of first
aid are often used in injuries of the extremities. Injuries of the neck, lower back,
elbow, knee and ankle may call for the use of supportive collars and braces during
recuperation, to guard against re-injury, and to assist healing and strengthening.
Rehabilitative exercises, as a physical therapy, comprise an important aspect of
professional counseling to assist recovery and prevent further strain. Counsel is often
given in such areas as dietary regimens, physical and mental attitudes affecting health,
personal hygiene, occupational safety, lifestyle habits, posture, rest, work, and the many
other activities of daily living which would enhance the effects of the chiropractic
adjustment. Chiropractic is concerned with the total individual; his or her health,
welfare, and survival. Professional chiropractic councils on diagnosis and internal
disorders, diagnostic imaging, behavioral health, neurology, nutrition, orthopedics,
physiological therapeutics, sports injuries and physical fitness, and technique strive to
keep the field abreast of the latest scientific and technological advancements providing
even more efficient methodology. |
| Consultation and Referral |
|
Under chiropractic care,
a patient is either treated or referred after a comprehensive examination, arrived at by
utilizing an orthopedic and neurological examination, an x-ray examination, laboratory
procedures, or whatever other procedures are necessary to determine the type health care
best suited for the patient's complaint. |
| References |
|
References we used for
this material is available upon request, simply E-Mail Dr.
Kunkle. |
|
| Other important questions are answered in the Questions & Answers section. |
|
|